Ação da Cidadania spoke with Matheus Alves Zanella, Senior Advisor at the Global Alliance for the Future of Food, an alliance of philanthropic foundations dedicated to transforming food systems, which is distinct from the Global Alliance against Hunger and Poverty.
Financing is one of the main challenges in turning international commitments into concrete action to tackle hunger and poverty. At a time when resources for international cooperation are declining, there is a growing need to bring together governments, financial institutions, philanthropic organizations, and civil society around priorities defined by countries themselves.
But to what extent can philanthropy contribute to this process? And how can we ensure that available resources strengthen public policies developed with meaningful social participation?
1. Why is financing currently one of the main challenges to turning the Global Alliance against Hunger and Poverty's implementation plans into reality?
Financing is a challenge for any development initiative, but it is particularly critical for an international initiative that depends to a large extent on international cooperation, meaning government-to-government aid, official development assistance (ODA). The paradox of the Alliance is that it has achieved remarkable political support, with more than one hundred countries joining, largely thanks to Brazil's international leadership and President Lula's role, at a time when these resources are shrinking at an unprecedented rate.
Donor countries, essentially those in the Global North, are adjusting their budgets under pressure from domestic demands, particularly the need to increase defense spending, and also in response to the rise of political currents that view foreign aid as unnecessary or ineffective and push for cuts. Not to mention the abrupt suspension of most US foreign aid, which virtually overnight disrupted the budgets of nearly the entire international cooperation system . OECD data indicate a 28% decline in total funding since its 2023 peak, to approximately USD 174 billion in 2025. A further reduction is projected for 2026.
One immediate consequence is that countries in the Global South where programs are being developed increasingly need to mobilize their own resources. This follows a counterpart funding model: if a multilateral bank or donor commits a certain amount, the national government contributes the same amount, twice as much, or even more. This was already happening, but it has intensified. There is certainly a real advantage to this approach: without domestic political commitment reflected in national budgets, international financing does not produce lasting results. It becomes a project that only the donor has an interest in seeing succeed, disconnected from political dynamics and sometimes even from social needs. The disadvantage is that middle-income and lower-middle-income countries have some capacity to mobilize domestic resources, while the lowest-income countries do not. Their public budgets are so limited that domestic resources cannot meet social needs.
This is particularly significant for the Alliance's model, as it is not a fund but a platform that seeks to align its members' support around country-led plans. Today, even programs backed by solid evidence of their effectiveness in reducing hunger and poverty struggle to secure funding. The challenge, therefore, is twofold: mobilizing more resources and making better use of those already available.
2. What is rarely discussed or widely understood about the role of philanthropy in this process, and what do you think people should know?
When government-to-government funding began to decline, many people's first reaction was: let's turn to philanthropy. Billionaires, who are doing very well financially, could indeed help fill the gap in international public financing. The problem is that, when you look at the numbers, the resources mobilized by philanthropy are far smaller than the overall decline in funding. According to the same OECD data, private philanthropy for development amounted to approximately USD 17 billion per year between 2020 and 2023, across all sectors (health, education, agriculture, etc.), including domestic philanthropy in developing countries. Cross-border flows, from one country to another, amounted to around USD 13 billion annually. The decline in official development assistance in 2025 alone, approximately USD 50 billion in real terms, is three to four times greater than the total amount private philanthropy mobilizes for development each year.
The situation is similar in our field. In a study we conducted in 2024–2025 on financing for regenerative agriculture, agroecology, and food systems, philanthropy accounted for only around 4% to 5% of the total. The rest came from government funding and some private-sector financing. This figure has certainly been growing, with more organizations and larger programs working on food-related issues, but it remains proportionally small. That said, the data should be treated with some caution. Governments report their figures systematically, while foundations only report voluntarily, meaning philanthropic contributions are probably underestimated. Even so, we are talking about vastly different orders of magnitude. Philanthropy will not fill this gap.
So what can, and should, philanthropy do? The key difference with philanthropic funding is its flexibility. The amounts are smaller and are not subject to the same scrutiny and procedures as public budgets, allowing them to be mobilized more quickly and directly. That is why we describe philanthropy as a lever: using smaller amounts of funding to remove bottlenecks, initiate processes, and fulfill functions that public funding struggles to support.
For example, developing a national program with international funding usually takes years, from the initial concept to the release of funds. It requires studies, technical design, political coordination, and, ideally, broad civil society participation in its joint development. Many governments struggle to finance this preparatory work, these consultations, and this co-creation process, precisely because public budgets are more tightly controlled. This is where philanthropy can make a difference. We believe that the role of philanthropic financing is not to replace public funding, but to work alongside it to overcome bottlenecks.
3. In practical terms, what can we do to ensure that governments, philanthropy, civil society, and other partners work together to implement national plans to combat hunger and poverty?
First, start with national plans and bring everyone to the same table. Rather than having each donor, bank, and foundation finance parallel projects, governments, multilateral banks, bilateral cooperation agencies, philanthropic organizations, and civil society need to be involved from the planning stage, aligning their support with priorities defined by the countries themselves. With less funding available, this alignment is essential for making implementation viable. The Alliance has taken some positive steps in this direction and is working to develop a Collaborative Financing Framework (CFF) to support this alignment.
Second, involve civil society in the development of policies, rather than merely consulting it at the end of the process. One distinctive feature of Brazil's leadership in building the Alliance is our experience of jointly developing food security policies through cooperation between government and civil society. Of course, we cannot be naive: relationships between the state and society vary greatly from country to country, and there is no guarantee that this approach will work in the same way everywhere. But the Brazilian experience demonstrates the difference that policies developed with social participation can make: they gain greater legitimacy, are more closely aligned with realities on the ground, and have greater continuity.
Third, provide direct support to civil society organizations. This is where I believe philanthropy can do more: provide flexible, medium- and long-term funding to strengthen these organizations' technical and policy-development capacities, enabling them to build relationships of trust with their governments and participate meaningfully in the design and implementation of national plans. This would also help sustain their role in advocacy and social accountability, functions that only civil society can fulfill.
Fourth, ensure transparency in financing. Effective coordination requires knowing who is funding what in each country, so that duplication can be avoided and gaps identified. Today, this is difficult, partly because of philanthropy itself, since the sector operates on a voluntary reporting basis. I believe that, from the governments' perspective, greater transparency would make an important contribution to predictability and planning.
About Matheus Alves Zanella
Matheus Alves Zanella is Senior Advisor at the Global Alliance for the Future of Food, a strategic alliance of 30 philanthropic organizations working to transform food systems, where he coordinates the organization's engagement in multilateral forums.
He has more than 15 years of experience in sustainable food systems and sustainability governance in Brazil and internationally, having led research and action-oriented projects in Latin America, Africa, and Asia.
He holds a PhD in Geography and Sustainable Development from the University of Bern and is the founder of Mesa pra Doze, a fine-dining initiative that uses local ingredients and tackles food waste, and Vinhos dos Vãos, which produces wines from fruits and the biodiversity of the Cerrado.

